Insomnia Cookies opening second Cincinnati location in OTR

Connor Fahrnbach and Dustin Marks with Colliers International represented Insomnia Cookies in the lease

Cincinnati Business Courier  

Insomnia Cookies, a national late-night bakery retailer based in Philadelphia and New York City, is opening its second Cincinnati location in Over-the-Rhine.

Insomnia Cookies has signed a long-term lease for 1,900 square feet of space at 1126 Main St., according to the company's brokers. The bakery backfills a space that was most recently occupied by Lucy Blue Pizza.

Connor Fahrnbach and Dustin Marks with Colliers International represented Insomnia Cookies in the lease. David Cawdrey, owner of Cawdrey Commercial Real Estate, represented the building owner, the Stough Group.

Read the full Cincinnati Business Courier article here. 

Related Experts

Dustin Marks

Vice President


Dustin has 13 years of brokerage experience. He is focused on assisting his nationally recognized clients with various real estate needs throughout Ohio & Kentucky. He is known for being a responsive, single point-of-contact for concepts that require in-depth knowledge of Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton, Lexington, Louisville and additional  tertiary markets.   

In addition to site selection expertise, Dustin has experience with site disposition and sub-leasing for national tenants, including: Beauty Brands, Captain D’s, Toys R Us and others. 

As an active member of the International Council of Shopping Centers, he currently serves as Central Division Next Generation Chair. His role as Central Division Chair is to provide leadership, structure and support for ICSC NextGen Programs within a 12-state division.

Dustin a graduate of the University of Cincinnati’s Real Estate program, which has been ranked among the top 5 most influential real estate research institutions in the nation. He is also a member of the University of Cincinnati’s Real Estate Roundtable Program, Urban Land Institute and the Commercial Real Estate Council of Greater Cincinnati. 

View expert

Connor Fahrnbach

Brokerage Associate


Connor joined Colliers International in 2016 as a broker-in-training.  During that time, he worked with the Research Team to develop a sound understanding of the Cincinnati commercial real estate market.  As part of the Retail Services Team, Connor provides both landlord and tenant representation to clients in Greater Cincinnati.  Connor's previous experiences in sales, marketing, and customer service provide a strong foundation for his entrance into retail brokerage.   

View expert